Muscle Shoals

For the history-minded, news that president Obama appears to be mulling a possible privatization of the TVA is at least a little bit ironic – and definitively ironic is the opposition that Tennessee’s two Republican Senators are already voicing against any such proposal.

Sen. George W. Norris (photo courtesy Digital Archives. Library of Congress)

Sen. George W. Norris (photo courtesy Digital Archives. Library of Congress)

During the 1920s, the virtues of public vs. private ownership of dams and plants to harness the Tennessee River’s giant hydroelectric potential were hotly debated. Originally, the U.S. government had begun construction on two dams and two nitrate plants near Muscle Shoals in northern Alabama during WW I. When the war ended before the project was completed, the Harding administration at first sought to transfer the installation into private ownership.

When Henry Ford became interested in purchasing the area, opposition coalesced around Senator George Norris, (progressive) Republican of Nebraska,  a constant thorn in the side of the three Republican preisdents of the 1920s. Norris argued that the Muscle Shoals facilities should remain government owned and operated and should become the center of a public works project to develop fertilizer, flood control, and power for the welfare of the people. In 1925 President Calvin Coolidge appointed a committee to investigate whether private or public administration would operate more efficiently. The Muscle Shoals Inquiry committee members, unwilling to resolve the controversial issue, declared the problem political rather than technical.

Norris continued to lead the fight to keep governmental control of the Muscle Shoals property. He demanded that the government administer the facility for the benefit of the people living in the Tennessee River Valley, and twice engineered the passage of bills calling for governmental control of the facilities, once in 1928 (pocket-vetoed by Coolidge) and once more in 1931, vetoed by Hoover, who had been a leading proponent of the privatization effort.

The stalemate ended in 1933 with the election of Franklin D. Roosevelt to the presidency. Roosevelt visited Muscle Shoals and charged the Tennessee Valley Authority (TVA) with planning the usage, development, and conservation of the natural resources in the Tennessee River basin to the combined advantage of agriculture, forestry, and flood prevention. While many consider the TVA a model of re-vitalization of an area through government projects, charges of unconstitutionality were lodged by private companies, which said that government ownership of utilities prevented private companies from entering the market. Conservative critics, including future president Ronald Reagan as early as the 1950s, criticized the TVA as a typical top-heavy big-government boondoggle.

2 thoughts on “Muscle Shoals

  1. It is interesting that the former President, dedicating his January 30, 1931 article to Muscle Shoals, comes down decisively against Congress ever outdoing private enterprise to accomplish something worthwhile from the project. “The management of Muscle Shoals demonstrates the utter hopeless of having any considerable business enterprise conducted by Congress…The thing to do with Muscle Shoals is to dispose of it to private interests, with suitable restrictions.” Government, even with the best of the best in office, is simply not designed to take the place of private industry and effort.

  2. I was saddened to learn that on the day President Coolidge died, January 5, 1933, the morning papers carried the news that President-elect FDR was visiting Muscle Shoals to determine whether it could support a public-works project -which, as was pointed out above, the Progressives always wanted. He must have been deeply troubled that all of the hard work of his presidency was being undone (tax cuts, budgeting, etc.) by successors who did not share his vision. It’s utterly ridiculous that our country still owns and operates the TVA and other relics from the New Deal. It’s further proof that the closest things to immortality are government programs.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s