Corporate villains

Today I saw the movie “Moon”, a riveting sci-fi yarn that is basically one actor’s showpiece – Sam Rockwell carries the full weight of the story, and he does it brilliantly. By all means go and see it…and I promise not to give away anything crucial here.  Much as I loved the film, I was put off by the tired cliché of corporate evildoers being predictably cast as villains. To me, the villainy of the corporation was the weak link in the story. Without giving away the twist, it seemed extremely far-fetched to me that a publicly traded company (and we’re not talking about a too-distant future here) would feel the need to resort to the trickery the plot called for…let alone get away with it for any length of time. Indeed, that same question is asked in the film “But why? Why would they do this?”. And maybe it’s my pro-market bias taking over, but I felt the answer (quotes are from memory) “Because they’re a corporation! They have investors, shareholders… ” was a bit lacking, though no doubt many will find it sufficient.

Yes, companies are made up of people. And yes, people make mistakes. And also yes, companies have at times engaged in questionable tactics. But I think it is wrong and misleading to characterize corporations as inherently evil, as Hollywood has been doing for much of the past couple of decades. This distorted image of corporations is seeping insidiously into the public mindset. And where is Calvin Coolidge in all this? It may be said that his presidency was the last that had an unrestricted pro-business tilt, as per his famous quote, “The business of America is business”. In effect, he and his predecessor Harding ran the country in the Gilded Age manner of a Cleveland, McKinley, or Taft, steering it rightward away from the trustbusting progressivism of Theodore Roosevelt and Woodrow Wilson, who -like Hollywood producers of today- liked to cast businessmen as villains.

To get back to the movie, I really feel a much more likely candidate for villain would have been the government, in the guise of some department or agency. Go see the movie, and ask yourself if a big, unaccountable and all-powerful government agency wouldn’t be much more likely to be the agent of evil. But I suppose that would be too avant-garde for the Hollywood of today.

1 thought on “Corporate villains

  1. Yes, but in a modern age not having coordinated policies leads to trouble. We don’t have a national energy policy despite the creation of a large Dept. of Energy with lots of patronage and bureaucrats (thank you Jimmy Carter!)

    Then given silly policies to prevent drilling for oil in Anwar or in readily accessible areas, oil companies are forced to deep water drilling and voila we have a crisis and spill since it’s more hazardous. Further the agencies involved in safety issues were and are incompetent.

    Then we have corrupt vested interests strip mining coal since Harry Byrd and Mitch McConnell want it that way for their districts. Not helpful.

    It’s more about government rules that screw things up than corrupt corporations.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s